Will machines in healthcare make surgeons obsolete?

After spending weeks researching, drafting, and discussing this topic with my peers and doctors, today marks my first publicly released article on this topic and on my blog.

I have chosen to investigate this question after seeing myself how sophisticated machinery are being used in hospitals, and this has made me, patients, prospective surgeons and doctors curious whether these machines are able to take over the major roles of a surgeon or a doctor in the future. Moreover, this idea of machines in healthcare making surgeons obsolete is trending currently as we are witnessing significant progression in technology, many of which applied to medicine.

The idea of machines making surgeons obsolete is already striking debate between different groups of people; some of who agree that this is very likely to happen in the future due to the frequent breakthroughs in the world of technology, and medicine – and others who disagree, predominantly due to the nature of machines never being able to reach the same complex and intelligent level as a human being. Today, we are lucky to have sophisticated machinery used in medicine to help assist through complicated procedures and operations. However up to now, there is no medical machine used in operations that can operate without the supervision of a surgeon or medical staff – so will we ever be able to develop a machine sophisticated enough to take over a surgeon’s position? The question targets medicine on a global scale and focuses on the revolution of medicine over the years to come. This is because the influence of the advancements in medical machinery will have a global effect on working surgeons; including whether the machines will make them obsolete or not. Naturally, More Economically Developed Countries (MEDC’s) countries are likely to adapt to the technological breakthroughs in medicine much faster than Less Economically Developed Countries (LEDC’s). This means, surgeons’ positions in work in relation to the development of medical machinery is likely to differ depending on the status of the country – however eventually it will have an effect on all surgeons, irrespective of the place of work.

With the recent boom in technological developments, the healthcare sector has been impacted positively allowing technology today to be heavily integrated into medicine. However up to now, there is no medical machine used in operations that can function without the supervision of a surgeon or medical staff, which strikes debate with the question. Evidence for the dominance of machines in surgical operations is growing, and the healthcare workforce patterns today are different from what they used to be over the previous years; this is predominately due to the introduction of numerous sophisticated surgical machinery, which have reduced the number of medical staff required for a given procedure. Spending on robotics is sharply increasing, as the demand for medical machinery is surging. Incorporating medical and surgical machinery today has improved treatment for patients, and created new methods for surgeons to perform operations. The Da Vinci surgical system is at the forefront of today’s technological medicine and is a prime example of what machines are capable of achieving; it demonstrates multiple features such as several robotic arms which enable it to function in several ways a surgeon wouldn’t be able to otherwise.

It is particularly important to recall that since the question raised focuses on future trends of healthcare, we are often using an inductive argument to advocate what may happen, however generalising from experience doesn’t necessarily suggest what can happen. We should recognise and appreciate the potential in machines, however machines, in the end, are no more than artificial intelligence created by humans. Therefore, after in depth research, it has become explicit that machines replicating the highly sophisticated system of the human mind, soul, and body and eventually making surgeons obsolete is almost virtually unfeasible.



8 Replies to “Will machines in healthcare make surgeons obsolete?”

  1. An interesting and well written article Mazyad! I would personally argue that eventually I think machines will make surgeons obsolete, just like what is happening currently in other professions. However, I do see where you are coming from in that surgery requires a very precise and analytical skill that comes from human nature.

    Keep up the great work! I’ll be interested to see what other great trends in healthcare we are currently seeing.

    1. Thank you! This question will always be controversial, but if you would like me to explain my reasoning for the question further using more information, and other evidence then please do email me.

  2. Before reading this blog i was on the edge regarding the benefits of the introduction of the Machinery that may one day replace doctors, however the research you have conducted and presented so eloquently has put my mind to ease.

  3. I personally believe your views are interesting and you have included a lot of valid reasons i.e The idea of machines making surgeons obsolete is extremely interesting as eventually in life computers will become more unique and advanced however, nothing will overcome the humans brain therefore I believe your conclusion is correct.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *